South Hill, with its tree-lined streets and stunning views of downtown Stillwater and the St. Croix River, is a quietly vibrant hub for food lovers. Beyond the postcard-perfect homes and historic architecture, a delicious array of restaurants, cafés, bakeries, and food trucks serve up flavors that have both locals and visitors raving. Whether you’re searching for a chic dinner spot, a cozy bakery, or a hidden lunch gem, South Hill’s evolving food scene offers plenty to savor. Here’s your go-to guide for discovering the best bites in this charming Stillwater neighborhood.
Where to Start: Dining Hotspots at the Heart of South Hill
A cluster of must-try eateries sits near the intersection of Third Street South and Churchill Street, just steps from scenic Pioneer Park. This area, also close to South Hill’s historic walking paths, is perfect for a progressive meal or a lingering afternoon coffee.
*Lolo American Kitchen and Craft Bar*
*Location: 233 Main St S (easy stroll north from South Hill proper)*
With a lively atmosphere and gastropub flair, Lolo is the “can’t-miss” spot for inventive American comfort food. Their signature sliders, house-cured bacon, and duck fat fries make for excellent sharing plates, while their cocktail menu draws a young, energetic crowd. Dishes range from $12-$25, making it accessible for a stylish dinner out without breaking the bank.
*The Green Bridge Coffee House*
*Location: 904 4th St S*
Tucked away on a quiet side street, this locally loved coffeehouse offers delicious pastries, rotating seasonal soups, and rich, expertly brewed local coffee. The homey vibe and leafy patio make it top choice for late brunches or leisurely mornings. Most menu items are under $10, with artisan toasts and house-made quiche drawing loyal regulars.
Hidden Gems for Memorable Meals
Exploring beyond the main drags, South Hill reveals hidden culinary treasures—some tucked into unexpected corners, others dazzling those “in the know”.
*Nelson’s Ice Cream*
*Location: 920 Olive St W (technically perched on the western edge of South Hill)*
This classic shop is an institution for families and dessert lovers alike. Legendary for their heaping “child size” portions and flavors from Black Licorice to Pirate’s Booty, Nelson’s draws people from all corners of Stillwater. In summer, lines wind down Olive Street, but the creamy spontaneity is always worth the wait. A single scoop (really a mound) will run you $4-6. Don’t miss the local favorite, “Lumberjack Sundae”—if you dare!
*The Chilkoot Café and Cyclery*
*Location: 826 4th St S*
This unique fusion of café and bike shop is quintessentially Stillwater. The Chilkoot is celebrated for its breakfast hash, delicious house-baked breads, and inventive weekend specials (think chorizo huevos rancheros or lemon ricotta pancakes). Fresh, locally sourced ingredients are the rule. Prices are modest, generally $9–$15 per plate; bonus points for the outdoor patio and velvety lattes served alongside bike tune-ups.
*South Hill Deli & Bakery*
*Location: 305 Churchill St E*
Open mornings and lunch, this neighborhood bakery crafts rustic country breads, sweet scones, and melt-in-your-mouth cinnamon rolls. Paninis and homemade chicken salad sandwiches are local favorites—many folks pair them with a cup of house soup for under $12. Check the daily chalkboard for fresh bakes and seasonal specials (apple hand pies in the fall are legendary).
Dinner with a Twist: Elevated Eats and Global Flavors
For dinner or a special night out, South Hill’s standouts hold their own alongside downtown’s culinary stars—sometimes with less fuss and fewer crowds.
*Brick & Bourbon*
*Location: 215 Main St S (just north of central South Hill, worth the pleasant stroll)*
Though it sits technically on Main Street, this gastro-lounge is beloved by South Hill residents and offers a sophisticated-yet-inviting menu. From bourbon-glazed pork chops ($24) to truffled mac and cheese ($15), the food has panache without pretension. Their curated bourbon list and craft cocktails also make it a go-to for happy hour and date nights.
*Thai Basil*
*Location: 1180 W Frontage Rd (a brief drive or longer walk southwest from the residential heart of South Hill)*
Locals craving a taste of Southeast Asia swear by Thai Basil’s fresh curries, spicy noodle bowls, and delicate stir-fries. The ambience is unfussy, while the flavors are bold and bright. Dishes hover around $14–$18. The green curry and pad kee mao are top picks; vegetarians will appreciate the many tofu-based options.
Sweet Treats and Quick Bites: Local Bakeries & Food Trucks
South Hill may be quaint, but its treats pack big flavor.
*Buttercream Bakery & Café*
*Location: 217 Churchill St E*
Specializing in cupcakes and celebration cakes, Buttercream is the go-to for birthdays, holidays, or “just because.” Their lemon-raspberry scones and chocolate croissants are local legends, ideally paired with small-batch hot cocoa or strong cold brew.
*Stillwater Eats Food Trucks*
*Location: Rotating, often near the junction of 4th St S and Churchill during events*
From farm-fresh tacos to wood-fired pizza, a rotating cast of food trucks pops up on South Hill’s main arteries during summer festivals and Friday evenings. Look for schedules announced via neighborhood boards and social media—favorites like The Big Red Wagon serve up barbecue sandwiches and loaded nachos (usually $8–$12 per plate).
Food Traditions: South Hill’s Neighborhood Flavors
Beyond individual hotspots, South Hill boasts a neighborly, unhurried food culture. Locals organize fall chili cook-offs and summer block party potlucks, where homemade pies and slow-cooked favorites are shared freely along Churchill Street. Weekends are made for ambling from brunch on 4th Street to ice cream at Nelson’s, then finishing an evening with cocktails just off Main.
Tips for Foodies Exploring South Hill
- Wear your walking shoes—sidewalks and leafy hills make for a beautiful, appetite-building stroll.
- Many cafés and bakeries open early, so beat the rush (and score the freshest pastries) before 9 AM.
- Reservations are a smart idea on weekends at Lolo or Brick & Bourbon, but most spots remain delightfully laid-back.
- Don’t hesitate to strike up conversation—locals are proud of South Hill’s food scene and quick to offer personal favorites.
South Hill, tucked above historic Stillwater, offers a slice of small-town charm with a dining scene that punches well above its weight. Whether you’re craving classic comfort food, a perfectly pulled espresso, or a sweet treat to-go, this neighborhood’s got a table (or bench, or patio seat) waiting for you.